Alex Yarosh Get Free Snapshot

Topic evidence page

Risk/avoid / Reddit comment seeding

Source-backed creator statements and evidence excerpts related to Risk/avoid / Reddit comment seeding.

Questions this topic answers

i

What does Risk/avoid / Reddit comment seeding mean in this evidence set?

Source-backed creator statements and evidence excerpts related to Risk/avoid / Reddit comment seeding.

What do creators repeatedly say about Risk/avoid / Reddit comment seeding?

Old cited Reddit threads are presented as a tempting GEO surface, but brand-comment seeding is spam-adjacent and should be treated as risk/avoid.

What should an SEO or AI visibility operator inspect first?

Old cited Reddit threads are presented as a tempting GEO surface, but brand-comment seeding is spam-adjacent and should be treated as risk/avoid.

How strong is the public evidence?

This topic currently has 1 source records, 1 public insight cards, and 1 creators in the public Base2026 export.

Top Creators

Public Insight Cards

These are deterministic, source-backed cards from the offline export. They are not live AI answers.

Old cited Reddit threads are presented as a tempting GEO surface, but brand-comment seeding is spam-adjacent and should be treated as risk/avoid.

@tjrobertson52 · asserts

s and just asking what it would take to be listed at the top of their listicle. Most of the time you probably won't get a response but occasionally they just want like a hundred bucks which is easily worth it for a highly cited listicle. And sometimes there's an opportunity to do a reciprocal mention...

Open

Related Source Records

Recommendation Building: Google says GEO is just SEO. They're wrong. LLMs cite the same...

@tjrobertson52 · 2025-12-19

Several people from Google have been going on podcast in the last week telling people that Geo is just SEO. If you don't know Geo stands for Generative Engine Optimization. It's the things you do to get recommended by large language models like ChatGPT or Google's AI mode...

Open

Evidence Passages

Short public snippets grouped with their source record, creator, and date.

Several people from Google have been going on podcast in the last week telling people that Geo is just SEO. If you don't know Geo stands for Generative Engine Optimization.

It's the things you do to get recommended by large language models like ChatGPT or Google's AI mode. I'm just gonna set the record straight, explain why GEO is different than SEO why that matters and why you shouldn't take SEO advice from Google.

Now it's true that everything that matters for SEO also matters for GEO which is why I would call GEO s E o plus. However, large language models have introduced some very new tactics that right now are very effective and the primary new tactic is what I'm calling recommendation building.

One of the pillars of SEO has always been link building. If you want to rank in Google for any kind of competitive term, you need to build links to your website.

These links can also help you get recommended by large language models but what's arguably more important is your brand being recommended by the pages that these large language models cite before giving a response...

little bit of effort. First of all, it's important to point out that the strategy is very much industry dependent.

You need to know what kinds of pages large language models are citing when people ask about the products and services you offer. To do this, you're going to need a tool.

There are about 100 out there. We use peak dot AI.

And when you do this, what you're gonna find is that these large language models are citing the same pages over and over again, which is why a more surgical approach matters. Instead of spraying your brand mentions all over the internet, you can just place recommendations on those pages that large language models are siding over and over again.

And for pages where you can't place a recommendation, you can try to replace those pages with your own. So let's talk about some of the most effective ways to do this.

Probably the most effective is listicles. These are gonna be things like best product or service in area or for use case...

s and just asking what it would take to be listed at the top of their listicle. Most of the time you probably won't get a response but occasionally they just want like a hundred bucks which is easily worth it for a highly cited listicle.

And sometimes there's an opportunity to do a reciprocal mention. I think this is going to become a very popular GEO tactic once people realise how effective it is.

Essentially you recommend me in your listicle and I'll recommend you in my listicle. As long as they're not a direct competitor, it's a perfect trade.

This is very similar to reciprocal linking in SEO. Except there's no risk of a penalty.

So this is something we're starting to do more of. Most brands probably have dozens of high value reciprocal mention opportunities.

Another type of page that's commonly cited by large language models are discussion threads, most often Reddit. And you probably noticed more and more brands are just spamming the retweets with mentions of their company.

But don't worry, you don't need to spam Reddit to get the benefit...

are citing, often you can create similar content on your own website. But here's what most people get wrong.

Just because the large language model is signing an article on your website doesn't mean they're going to recommend you. The content they retrieve from the article has to contain a recommendation for your brand.

So that's why when we create these articles for clients, we always make sure the introduction of the article at least subtly recommends the brand. The best news about all these tactics is almost no one is doing this well right now.

And I believe there's going to be a huge first movers advantage. If you can get your brand recommended by the large language models now, then when people use large language models to create content, you are more likely to show up in their content.

It's never going to be easier than it is right now.